Operational modes and Catalog options

latest update: 2014-10-13    

Introduction

In plant design we sometimes have to model "operational modes", whereas in product catalogs we often see "options". Both are in fact identical, and hence they are modeled identically.

An operational mode is a way the facility must function, and hence be configured.

EXAMPLES 

  1. A plant must be able to accept two different feed stocks as input;
  2. A TV set must be able to handle 100 channels;
  3. A computer must be able to handle a range of programs.

Options in a product catalog are ways in which a product may be configured.

EXAMPLES

  1. A valve model comes in a series of sizes, materials, etc.
  2. A car model comes in a series of colors, engine types, accessories, etc.

It is important to note that there must be a choice between more than one operational mode or option. If not, then the optionality is modeled using cardinalities.

This paper explains the model, as a sequel to the paper "Life cycle of a Class".

Modeling

An example model:

Mode 1 and Mode 2 in above example could be the Modes of Operation ("cases") "Normal Operation" and "Regeneration". For each of these two modes a subclass of the requirements class of P-101 is defined. Please keep in mind that the information that is common for both modes is to be stored against the common superclass.

An unexpected example

In the topic of mapping a line list the situation occurred that a line seemingly has two sizes. In fact that line has one size and one smaller size for drains and vents. That is a case like in above diagram, where X1 is one size and Y1 the other size. The rest of the requirements is the same for both.