Hi Glen, I have to admit that I have a concern if you see P-101 as being part of the RDL. [HT] I said "Hell no!", so how on earth can you say that P-101 is part of the RDL? When we reviewed the workflow of creating project data as classes, this meant we put a load on the modelling team of project as...

Hi Victor,

Here is the modified template:



Regards,
Hans

Hi Victor, I think this new topic requires systematic changes of on the typing and relationships you are touching below. I believe you have them ready? Probable you start that, and I'll add my reasons - why it doesn't really contradicts FOL view of the standard. [HT] I will do that. I don't understa...

Sorry for the typo, I clicked the Submit instead of the Preview button
Hans

Hi Keith, You wrote: I am struggling with is why do we think it appropriate to model it as a CLASS prior to installation and as an Individual afterwards [HT] The manufacturer of the materialized physical object designs his pump model as a class with, hopefully for him, many members. Likewise we have...

Hi Keith, Much more than I have written in: - http://www.15926.info/plant-design/index.htm - http://www.15926.info/functional-vs-materializedPO/functional-vs-materialized-physical-object.htm - http://www.15926.info/functional-physical-object/index.htm - http://www.15926.info/cradle-to-grave/index.ht...

Hi Victor, This is a reply to both posts. Post 1 1. Approval of this modeling approach means that we agree that a template statement can occupy a role in a template statement. I'm supporting this idea, but it has a strong opposition also, and we've to bring this discussion to the attention of a broa...

Hi Pavel, Re 1) - Actually it would be something like a "Specialization of Class of V-101 on Nov. 14 2011", but more meaningful for humans would be "Class of V-101 has a design pressure of 100 barg starting Nov. 14 2011". That specialization is made for one template only. The Ur-Class has, so to spe...

Hi Onno, Basically it is the same problem that occurs with finding a previous temporal part of a possible individual that needs to be "ended". Let me give an example: 1) On Nov. 14th 2011 the design pressure of vessel V-101 (a Class in our plant design) was recorded as 100 barg 2) On March 20th 2012...

Hi Victor, A TemplateStatement (part 8) is a combination of ClassOfInformationRepresentation AND MultidimensionalObject. Part 2 allows that combination since they are not in a ONEOF subtype relation with AbstractObject. So, yes, specialization is possible in the OWL code, but that is not what you ha...